5.3: THE BILL OF RIGHTS

Many of the aspects of our nation’s laws and criminal justice systems have been molded by the United States’ founding documents. The foundation of civil liberties is the Bill of Rights, the ten amendments added to the Constitution in 1791 to restrict what the national government may do (Lumen).

The state conventions that ratified the Constitution obtained promises that the new Congress would consider adding a Bill of Rights. James Madison—the key figure in the Constitutional Convention and an exponent of the Constitution’s logic in the Federalist papers—was elected to the first House of Representatives. Keeping a campaign promise, he surveyed suggestions from state-ratifying conventions and zeroed in on those most often recommended. He wrote the amendments not just as goals to pursue but as commands telling the national government what it must do or what it cannot do. Congress passed twelve amendments, but the Bill of Rights shrank to ten when the first two (concerning congressional apportionment and pay) were not ratified by the necessary nine states.

The first eight amendments that were adopted address particular rights. The Ninth Amendment addressed the concern that listing some rights might undercut unspoken natural rights that preceded government. It states that the Bill of Rights does not “deny or disparage others retained by the people.” This allows for unnamed rights, such as the right to travel between states, to be recognized. We discussed the Tenth Amendment in module 2, as it has more to do with states’ rights than individual rights.

The Rights

Even before the addition of the Bill of Rights, the Constitution did not ignore civil liberties entirely. It states that Congress cannot restrict one’s right to request a writ of habeas corpus giving the reasons for one’s arrest. It bars Congress and the states from enacting bills of attainder (laws punishing a named person without trial) or ex post facto laws (laws retrospectively making actions illegal). It specifies that persons accused by the national government of a crime have a right to trial by jury in the state where the offense is alleged to have occurred and that national and state officials cannot be subjected to a “religious test,” such as swearing allegiance to a particular denomination.

The Bill of Rights contains the bulk of civil liberties. Unlike the Constitution, with its emphasis on powers and structures, the Bill of Rights speaks of “the people,” and it outlines the rights that are central to individual freedom.

The main amendments fall into several broad categories of protection, as follow:

1. Freedom of expression (I)
2. The right to “keep and bear arms” (II)
3. The protection of person and property (III, IV, V)
4. The right not to be “deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law” (V)
5. The rights of the accused (V, VI, VII)
6. Assurances that the punishment fits the crime (VIII)
7. The right to privacy implicit in the Bill of Rights

The Bill of Rights and the States

Later we discuss the Fourteenth Amendment, added to the Constitution in 1868, and how its due process clause, which bars states from depriving persons of “life, liberty, or property, without due process of law,” is the basis of civil rights. The Fourteenth Amendment is crucial to civil liberties, too. The Bill of Rights restricts only the national government; the Fourteenth Amendment allows the Supreme Court to extend the Bill of Rights to the states.

The Supreme Court exercised its new power gradually. The Court followed selective incorporation: for the Bill of Rights to extend to the states, the justices had to find that the state law violated a principle of liberty and justice that is fundamental to the inalienable rights of a citizen. Table 1, “The Supreme Court’s Extension of the Bill of Rights to the States,” below, shows the years when many protections of the Bill of Rights were applied by the Supreme Court to the states; some have never been extended at all (Lumen).

Table 5.1 The Supreme Court’s Extension of the Bill of Rights to the States

Date	Amendment	Right	Case
1897	Fifth	Just compensation for eminent domain	Chicago, Burlington & Quincy Railroad v. City of Chicago
1925	First	Freedom of speech	Gitlow v. New York
1931	First	Freedom of the press	Near v. Minnesota
1932	Fifth	Right to counsel	Powell v. Alabama (capital cases)
1937	First	Freedom of assembly	De Jonge v. Oregon
1940	First	Free exercise of religion	Cantwell v. Connecticut
1947	First	Non-establishment of religion	Everson v. Board of Education
1948	Sixth	Right to public trial	In Re Oliver
1949	Fourth	No unreasonable searches and seizures	Wolf v. Colorado
1958	First	Freedom of association	NAACP v. Alabama
1961	Fourth	Exclusionary rule excluding evidence obtained in violation of the amendment	Mapp v. Ohio
1962	Eighth	No cruel and unusual punishment	Robinson v. California
1963	First	Right to petition government	NAACP v. Button
1963	Fifth	Right to counsel (felony cases)	Gideon v. Wainwright
1964	Fifth	Immunity from selfincrimination	Mallory v. Hogan
1965	Sixth	Right to confront witnesses	Pointer v. Texas
1965	Fifth, Ninth, and others	Right to privacy	Griswold v. Connecticut
1966	Sixth	Right to an impartial jury	Parker v. Gladden
1967	Sixth	Right to a speedy trial	Klopfer v. N. Carolina
1969	Fifth	Immunity from double jeopardy	Benton v. Maryland
Sixth	Sixth	Right to counsel (all crimes involving jail terms)	Argersinger v. Hamlin
2010	Second	Right to keep and bear arms	McDonald v. Chicago
Rights not extended to the states
Third		No quartering of soldiers in private dwellings
Fifth		Right to grand jury indictment
Seventh		Right to jury trial in civil cases under common law
Eighth		No excessive bail
Eighth		No excessive fines